Broker Check

Taxable vs. Tax-Deferred vs. Tax-Free

Koehler Wealth Calculators

Pay the Tax Now, Later, or Along the Way?

Every dollar you save lands in one of three tax buckets. A taxable account is taxed along the way. A tax-deferred account, like a traditional 401(k) or IRA, is taxed when you withdraw. A tax-free account, like a Roth, is taxed before you contribute. See how the same savings could compare after taxes in each one.

Your numbers stay on your screen. Nothing you enter is saved or sent anywhere.

← Back to All Calculators

Your Numbers

What You Keep After Taxes

Most after-tax value

—

Yours to spend Taxes due when you withdraw

It Comes Down to When You Pay

Tax-deferred vs. tax-free is mostly a bet on your future tax rate. If your tax rate in retirement is lower than it is today, deferring the tax tends to come out ahead. If it is higher, paying now with a Roth tends to win. If the two rates are the same, the results are identical. Try changing the retirement tax rate to see the balance shift.

Taxable accounts usually trail — but they earn their place. Taxes on dividends and gains slow growth along the way. In exchange, you get flexibility: no contribution limits, no age restrictions on withdrawals, and long-term gains taxed at rates that are often lower than ordinary income.

Nobody knows their future tax rate for certain. Tax laws change, incomes change, and required minimum distributions from tax-deferred accounts can push retirees into higher brackets than they expected. That is why many people choose to hold money in all three buckets. Having options in retirement lets you decide each year which account to draw from based on your tax situation at the time.

I talk more about how taxes shape a retirement plan on my Tax Planning page.

Assumptions Behind This Calculator

Each scenario starts with the same pre-tax income set aside at the start of every year. The tax-deferred account receives the full amount. The tax-free and taxable accounts receive what is left after paying income tax at your current rate.

All three accounts earn the same constant rate of return. In the taxable account, 2% of the return is paid as dividends and taxed each year at your investment tax rate, with the after-tax amount reinvested. The rest is growth that is taxed only when sold.

For comparison, each account is valued as if it were fully withdrawn at the end of the period. In practice, withdrawals are usually spread over many years, which can change the taxes owed.

Tax rates stay the same throughout. Contribution limits, income limits for Roth contributions, early withdrawal penalties, required minimum distributions, and additional taxes such as the net investment income tax are not modeled. Roth withdrawals are assumed to be qualified.

Return rates are limited to 12% and tax rates to 60%.

Wondering Which Bucket Your Next Dollar Belongs In?

The right mix depends on your income today, what you expect in retirement, and the accounts you already have. A conversation can help you sort it out. If it turns out I am not the right fit, I will tell you that too.

Schedule a Conversation

Explore more calculators

This calculator is a hypothetical illustration provided for educational purposes only. It does not represent the performance of any specific investment and is not a guarantee of future results. Actual returns will vary and may be negative. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Tax laws are complex and subject to change, and the tax treatment shown is simplified. Results do not reflect fees or expenses. This information is not intended as tax or legal advice. Please consult a qualified tax professional regarding your individual situation.

Some IRAs have contribution limitations and tax consequences for early withdrawals. Distributions from traditional IRAs and employer sponsored retirement plans are taxed as ordinary income and, if taken prior to reaching age 59 ½, may be subject to an additional 10% IRS tax penalty. For complete details, consult your tax advisor or attorney. Converting from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA is a taxable event. A Roth IRA offers tax free withdrawals on taxable contributions. To qualify for the tax-free and penalty-free withdrawal or earnings, a Roth IRA must be in place for at least five tax years, and the distribution must take place after age 59 ½ or due to death, disability, or a first-time home purchase (up to a $10,000 lifetime maximum). Depending on state law, Roth IRA distributions may be subject to state taxes.