Sequence of Returns Illustrator
Koehler Wealth Calculators
Does It Matter When the Bad Years Come?
While you are saving, the order of your returns barely matters. Once you start withdrawing, it can matter a great deal. This illustrator uses actual S&P 500 returns from 1999 forward to show how two retirees with the same savings and the same withdrawals can end up in very different places — based only on timing.
Your numbers stay on your screen. Nothing you enter is saved or sent anywhere.
Set Up the Comparison
What to Compare
Your Numbers
Two Retirees, One Market
Retiree A
—
Retiree B
—
The difference timing made
—
Why Timing Matters Once Withdrawals Begin
When you are still saving, a bad year early on hurts on paper, but you are not selling anything. Your shares are still there when the market recovers. Once you start withdrawing, a downturn means selling investments at lower prices to pay your bills. Those shares are gone, and they do not participate in the recovery.
That is sequence-of-returns risk. Try the same returns, opposite order comparison: both retirees earn the exact same set of annual returns, with the same average, yet end up with very different balances. The only thing that changed is which years came first.
Nobody can predict when the next downturn will come. What a plan can do is make sure a bad market early in retirement never forces you to sell at the wrong time — by separating the money you will need in the next few years from the money that has time to recover. I walk through two complete case studies, year by year, on my Retirement Planning page, where you can also download the free guide.
How This Illustrator Works
Returns are actual annual S&P 500 total returns (dividends reinvested) for the years shown. Each year, the balance earns that year’s return, and the withdrawal is then taken at the end of the year. Withdrawals rise each year by the increase you enter.
In the cash reserve comparison, Retiree B’s living expenses for the first years are paid from a separate reserve that is not shown. When Retiree B begins withdrawing from the portfolio, withdrawals start at your first-year amount and rise from there.
In the opposite-order comparison, both retirees withdraw the same amounts in the same years. Only the order of the returns is reversed.
Comparisons run up to 20 years, ending no later than the most recent full year of data. Taxes, fees, and expenses are not included.
Source: S&P 500 annual total returns, slickcharts.com.
Is Your Plan Ready for a Rough Start?
You cannot choose the market you retire into. You can choose a plan that does not depend on it. A conversation can show how your income would hold up if the first few years go badly. If it turns out I am not the right fit, I will tell you that too.
Schedule a ConversationThese are hypothetical examples using actual historical S&P 500 index total returns for the years shown. They do not represent any actual account, product, client, or investor, and do not reflect taxes, fees, or expenses of any kind. Individuals cannot invest directly in an index. Past performance does not guarantee future results, and this illustration should not be construed as a projection or promise of any specific outcome. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. There is no assurance that any investment strategy will be successful. This information is not intended as tax or legal advice. Please consult a qualified professional regarding your individual situation.