Broker Check

Rent vs. Buy

Koehler Wealth Calculators

Is Buying Really Better Than Renting?

Buying builds equity, but it also comes with closing costs, maintenance, property taxes, and selling costs. Renting keeps you flexible and frees your down payment to be invested. Which comes out ahead depends mostly on one thing: how long you stay. Compare both paths over the time frame you have in mind.

The rates and costs shown are examples — adjust them to match your situation and your area. Your numbers stay on your screen. Nothing you enter is saved or sent anywhere.

← Back to All Calculators

Your Numbers

Buying vs. Renting

After your time frame

—

If you buy

—

If you rent and invest

—

Buy Rent and invest

What you would walk away with if you sold or stopped renting in each year, after selling costs.

What Tips the Balance

Time is the biggest factor. Buying comes with large one-time costs: closing costs going in and selling costs coming out. It takes years of appreciation and principal payments to earn those back. That is why renting often comes out ahead over short periods and buying tends to win the longer you stay.

Renting only wins if the difference is invested. The rent path assumes your down payment, closing costs, and any monthly savings are invested rather than spent. Without that discipline, much of renting’s financial advantage disappears.

Owners pay costs renters do not see. Maintenance, repairs, property taxes, insurance, and HOA dues add up. A common estimate for maintenance alone is about 1% of the home’s value each year, and older homes can run higher.

Not every reason is financial. Stability, control over your space, schools, and simply wanting a place of your own all matter. So does flexibility if your career or family plans may change. If you are leaning toward buying, my home affordability and mortgage calculators can help with the next steps.

Assumptions Behind This Calculator

The buyer pays a down payment and closing costs up front, then a fixed-rate mortgage payment plus property tax, insurance, HOA dues, and maintenance each month. Property tax and maintenance are based on the home’s current value, and insurance rises with home values. When the home is sold, selling costs are subtracted from its value along with the remaining loan balance.

The renter invests the down payment and closing costs from the start. Each month, whichever path costs less invests the difference, so both paths spend the same total. Rent rises once a year at the rate you enter. Investments earn a constant return, compounded monthly.

Income taxes, mortgage interest deductions, capital gains taxes, private mortgage insurance, and moving costs are not included. Home values and investment returns can fall as well as rise.

A Home Decision Is a Plan Decision

Whether to buy, and when, affects your savings, your cash flow, and your flexibility for years. A conversation can help you weigh it against your other goals. If it turns out I am not the right fit, I will tell you that too.

Schedule a Conversation

Explore more calculators

This calculator is a hypothetical illustration provided for educational purposes only and is not a guarantee of future results. Home values, rents, interest rates, and investment returns will vary, and home values and investments can lose value. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Rates and costs shown are examples and are not a quote or an offer of credit. Koehler Wealth does not originate mortgages. This information is not intended as tax, legal, or real estate advice. Please consult a qualified professional regarding your individual situation.