Should I Pay Down Debt or Invest?
Koehler Wealth Calculators
Where Should Your Extra Dollars Go?
If you have extra money each month, you can put it toward a loan or invest it. Paying down debt earns a certain return — the interest you no longer pay. Investing may earn more or less, with no guarantee. Compare both paths and see the return your investments would need to come out ahead.
Your numbers stay on your screen. Nothing you enter is saved or sent anywhere.
Your Numbers
Two Paths, Same Dollars
Pay down the debt first
—
Invest the extra instead
—
Difference after
—
Net position over time: investments minus the remaining loan balance.
More Than a Math Problem
Paying off debt is a guaranteed return. Every dollar of principal you pay off saves interest at your loan’s rate, with no market risk. Investing has the potential to earn more over time, but returns are never guaranteed, and some years are negative. Comparing the two means comparing a sure thing with a range of possibilities.
Order of priorities often matters more than the answer. Many households start with a few steps before this question comes up: building an emergency fund, contributing enough to capture any employer retirement match, and paying off high-interest credit card debt. After those, the choice between low-rate debt and investing becomes more personal.
Taxes and timing can shift the numbers. Investments held in taxable accounts may owe tax on growth, while money in retirement accounts may grow tax-deferred. Some loan interest, such as mortgage interest for those who itemize, may be deductible. Enter an investment return that reflects what you would actually keep after taxes.
Peace of mind counts too. For some people, being debt-free is worth more than a possible higher return. There is no wrong answer to valuing that. My emergency fund, workplace plan, and debt payoff calculators can help with the steps that usually come first.
Assumptions Behind This Calculator
Both paths use the same total dollars each month: your regular loan payment plus your extra amount. In the “pay down” path, the extra goes to the loan; once it is paid off, the full amount is invested. In the “invest” path, the extra is invested from the start, and once the loan is paid off on schedule, the regular payment is invested too.
The loan has a fixed rate with monthly interest. Investments earn the same constant return every year, compounded monthly. Actual returns vary and may be negative.
Taxes, fees, prepayment penalties, and tax deductions for interest are not modeled separately. Return rates are limited to 12%.
Decide With the Whole Picture in View
The right balance between paying down debt and investing depends on your rates, your goals, and how you feel about risk. A conversation can help you weigh them together. If it turns out I am not the right fit, I will tell you that too.
Schedule a ConversationThis calculator is a hypothetical illustration provided for educational purposes only. It does not represent the performance of any specific investment and is not a guarantee of future results. Actual returns will vary and may be negative. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Results do not reflect taxes, fees, or expenses. This information is not intended as tax, legal, or credit advice. Please consult a qualified professional regarding your individual situation.