Broker Check

Buy vs. Lease a Vehicle

Koehler Wealth Calculators

Lower Payment or Lower Cost?

A lease usually comes with a lower monthly payment. Buying usually costs more each month but leaves you with a car that still has value. The fair comparison is what each one actually costs you over the same period. Enter a lease offer and a loan offer for the same vehicle to compare.

The numbers shown are examples — use the figures from the offers you receive. Your numbers stay on your screen. Nothing you enter is saved or sent anywhere.

← Back to All Calculators

Your Numbers

Cost Over the Lease Term

The difference

—

Lease

—

Buy with a loan

—

Where the money goes

Leasing and Buying, Side by Side

A lease pays for the part of the car you use. Your payments cover the vehicle’s expected drop in value during the lease, plus financing charges and fees. At the end, you hand the car back with nothing to sell. Buying costs more each month, but every payment builds equity you keep.

Buying usually wins the longer you keep the car. Cars lose the most value in their first few years. Once a loan is paid off, the years you drive without a payment are where ownership pulls ahead. Someone who keeps cars for eight or ten years often comes out well ahead of someone who leases continuously.

Leasing can make sense in some situations. Drivers who want a newer car every few years, who drive predictable miles, or who use a vehicle for business may find leasing worth the cost. Watch the fine print: mileage limits, excess wear charges, and fees at signing and turn-in all add up.

Either way, fit the payment to your budget. A car payment is one of the largest monthly commitments many households have. My budget calculator can show how it fits, and my refinance calculator can help if you already have a car loan.

Assumptions Behind This Calculator

Both options are compared over the length of the lease. The lease cost includes the amount due at signing, all monthly payments, the turn-in fee, any excess mileage charges, and tax on the lease. The buying cost includes the down payment, tax on the purchase price, and loan payments made during the lease term, minus the car’s value at the end of that period less the remaining loan balance.

The car’s value at the end of the term is the percentage of the price you enter. Lease residual values are often a reasonable estimate. Actual resale or trade-in value will depend on the vehicle, its condition, and the market.

Tax rules for purchases and leases vary by state, so the same tax rate is applied to the purchase price and to lease payments for simplicity. Insurance, maintenance, registration, excess wear charges, and what your down payment could have earned elsewhere are not included.

Big Purchases Belong in the Plan

Cars, homes, and other large purchases shape your cash flow for years. A conversation can help you fit them into the rest of your goals. If it turns out I am not the right fit, I will tell you that too.

Schedule a Conversation

Explore more calculators

This calculator is a hypothetical illustration provided for educational purposes only. The figures shown are examples and are not a quote or an offer of credit or lease terms. Actual costs depend on the dealer, lender, vehicle, your credit, and the terms of your agreement. Vehicle values will vary. This information is not intended as tax or legal advice. Please consult a qualified professional regarding your individual situation.